Ì A Voice in the Wind Ö Download by è Francine Rivers This story follows Hadassah, a Judean Christian brought to Rome after the fall of Jerusalem, Marcus and Julia, two young Roman citizens, and Atretes, a German warrior and chieftain defeated in battle and brought to Rome as a gladiator.
The good This book was head and shoulders above any other Christian fiction I ve read, in terms of willingness to write about the seamier things as well as simple writing talent In general, I was pleased with how the author portrayed Rome She didn t shy away from the seedier aspects, including the immense of amounts of sex all kinds of sex that the Romans enjoyed Too frequently Christian authors get squeamish and try to sanitize history for the sake of their little Christian book, but she really went for it And not just with the sex, but with the violence of the arena as well And in general, her history was good, she had a pretty good understanding of how Romans thought, why they disliked Jews as well as Christians, and why they thought both sects were dangerous, crazy, and worthy of being despised and scorned.
The bad Oh, Hadassah You little stereotypical Christian heroine Mary Sue She drove me nuts She was so damn perfect In fact, her one flaw, as portrayed in the book, was that she DIDN T go around proclaiming for love for Jesus to everyone she met Frankly, I did not find this a flaw I found this her one redeeming feature to her otherwise sickeningly sweet personality Ugh, Hadassah, so uselessly twee Julia had the opposite problem she too was rather flat though in the other direction You can tell the author tried to give her a character arc, but it doesn t quite scan.
she seems to jump from personality to personality without much motivation or exploration.
The Ugly Ok, first and foremostwell, there wasn t much of a plot Things just kind of happened, and then other things happened, and then, look More things They happened But none of it never seemed to lead anywhere Maybe this is because it s part of a trilogy, but each book needs to feel somewhat complete within itself A book should not be 500 pages and yet have no plot Second, the author got a couple of historical facts really really wrong First, Romans did not have a sense of heterosexuality and homosexuality like we do There were only 2 roles pitchers and catchers Roman male citizens were always pitchers, women and slaves were always catchers While a Roman male would be scorned for being buggered BY another male, as long as he was the one doing the schtupping, it didn t matter whether it was a male or female Romans viewed it the same Second, she got her history on abortion all mixed up First, there actually WERE laws against abortion she has a character say there s not one but it was not homicide it was viewedas theft against the father or master, if the pregnant woman was a slave because he lost a potential investment Second, the Romans never questioned whether fetuses were babies or not, they took the Greek view of thinking of fetuses asplant like until they drew breath Also, Hadassah s reactions about all these things were ridiculous Anyone who grew up in that era would have been inured to these things, whether they agreed with them or notwhy is she acting like all this stuff is brand new information No.
Considering this was written pre internet, I m willing to give her the benefit of the doubt of not being able to readily find this rather obscure information, but I still resent her shoe horning a modern issue onto a plot device that made NO SENSE historically I still haven t decided whether I m going to read 2 and 3 They focuson Marcus and Atretes, both of whom I liked WAYthan Hadassah Still, I m afraid we haven t seen the last of her, and I don t want to read 1000pages of no plot.
I have a different perspective than most of the Goodreads reviewers of A Voice in the Wind An avoider of the romance genre both Christian and secular I loved the first part of the book, depicting the fall of Jerusalem and Haddassah s transition to Roman slavery I previously dispassionately stored in my mind the historic fact that losers in wars became the slaves of their conquerors, but Ms Rivers long, emotive description made the horror and depth of that trauma real to me in a manner I hadn t considered It almost brought tears to my eyes thinking about how many people have suffered this devastation I also found interesting Ms Rivers depiction of Ancient Rome I appreciated that the way she informed the reader of its depravity without either glamorizing it with too much detail or sanitizing it into a toga wearing society of butterflies and rainbows by ignoring its corruption However, when the story devolved into a maudlin romance I began rolling my eyes, losing interest and getting irritated I recognize that Ms Rivers was a successful romance novelist before her conversion to Christianity and accept that this professional strength will necessarily inform her subsequent work It s just not my cup of tea.
On a spiritual level, I appreciated Haddassah s struggle with fear in identifying herself as a Christian and sharing the gospel, but found her perfection to be abrasive What a blessing that Haddassah was able to experience such violent loss and slavery without any emotional damage that hindered her from responding as a perfect Christian in every circumstance But, then, perfection or near perfection in heroes and heroines is a staple in the romantic genre.
So, A Voice in the Wind was a mixed bag for me I liked it ok, but I will not be reading its sequel.
The City Was Silently Bloating In The Hot Sun, Rotting Like The Thousands Of Bodies That Lay Where They Had Fallen In Street Battles With This Opening Sentence, A Voice in the Wind Transports Readers Back To Jerusalem During The First Jewish Roman War, Some Seventy Years After The Death Of Christ Following The Prides And Passions Of A Group Of Jews, Romans And Barbarians Living At The Time Of The Siege, The Narrative Is Centered On An Ill Fated Romance Between A Steadfast Slave Girl, Hadassah, And Marcus, The Brother Of Her Owner And A Handsome Aristocrat After Surviving The Massacre Of Her Family And The Destruction Of Jerusalem By The Romans, Hadassah Is Captured And Sold To A Well To Do Merchant S Family Brought To Rome, She Is Pressed Into Service As A Personal Slave To Hedonistic Julia Valerian Hadassah Struggles To Walk In The Footsteps Of Jesus And To Treat Her Masters In A Manner In Keeping With His Teachings, But She Is Forced To Keep Her Religious Identity A Secret In Order To Survive Confused And Alone, She Has Only Her Faith To Cling To As She Tries To Subtly Bring God Into The Lives Of Her Captors Reckless, Impulsive, And Villainous, Julia Tries To Undermine Hadassah At Every Turn But Julia S Brother, Marcus, Is A Different Sort Altogether Is It Possible For A Love Between Hadassah And Marcus To Flourish Considering Not Only Their Differing Stations In Life, But Also The Gap Between Hadassah S Unrelenting Faith And Marcus Lack Of Belief In Anything Simultaneously, Atretes, A Captured Soldier From Germania, Is Forced To Become A Gladiator This Is The Time Of Rome S Decline And The Decadence Of A Civilization On The Verge Of Self Destruction Serves As A Powerful Backdrop To The Barbarian S Struggle For Survival In The Arena I just finished this book it made me feel different, it made me wants to change and become like Hadassah This book is a good representation of a Christian woman, and the faith, and peace that all of our hearts are looking for It s amazing when I read it I became her Walking in the darkness of the garden to pray to God, the faithful slave girl that served with desire and love to the people who she learned to love Everything about her wasn t perfect because she feared, but at the end when she has to choose between Life and God, she picked God and went into the Arena to be ripped apart by Lions It is sad to know that someone with her faith had died, but because of the quote that said at the end But the eyes of the Lord are watching over those who fear him, who rely upon his steady love He will keep them from death Psalm 33 18 I knew that she wouldn t die God would protect her and she would live This is the most amazing book to read about how hard it is some time to come to Christ and how hard to overcome your fear She shows us the way to be faithful even when she thinks he fails She would pray and God would answer I learned that he is A Voice in the Wind and he is the silent watcher and protector of his people Everyone should read this amazing book it will change how they look at life I m about to start on the second book An Echo in the Darkness, and can t wait to see how muchthis other book will change my life and bring me closer to my saver Jesus Christ I know through this book God has something new to show me about him, and I m ready to see what it is God bless everyone who is reading this Series The mark Of the Lion, May the Lord show you his power and change your life with every word that is written within this these books.
first read May 13 to May 18, 2013first reread January 6 16, 2016This.
I couldn t begin to describe to you the emotions this book brings out in me Happiness, sadness, disgust, anger, love, joy, terror, hate, heartbreakI just love this book so much Its not even this bookTHIS author, Francine Rivers.
her writing is beyond beautiful, and her stories are not just stories, they are filled, absolutely filled with things that really just, make you think This story takes place in old Roman timesbut there was so much that you could compare with the world today This is one of those books that many won t want to read, and so they won t, but its definitely one that everyone should read.
Wonderful book Francine Rivers used to write secular novels, but found her calling was with Christian stories I found myself pulled into the story, wanting to know what happens next, and being fascinated with the Roman way of life Knowing how Francine Rivers writes, I m sure the historical accounts of everyday Roman life is pretty accurate Yes, there is love and romance, but only hints of sex Nothing tawdry The descriptions of the Roman gladiator fights were fairly graphic, not to mention the accounts of people being fed to the lions as entertainment Very sad.
Don t bother reading this if you re not willing to read the second in the series You will want to know how it continues Also, if you re put off by the Christian theme, she is probably not the author for you I m still surprised how people become so inflamed by a blatant Christian theme in a Christian novel, by a Christian writer Well of course It would be like reading a vegetarian cookbook and not expecting an obvious vegetarian way of life is better thread through out Not to mention a strong possibility of the dangers of being a carnivore being pointed outthan once As Homer Simpson would say.
d oh I read this book back in 2003 and LOVED it It was possibly one of the best books I have ever read I never got around to reading the next two in the series, so I am re reading it now, so that I can continue with the series update Just finished re reading this and I am so glad I did, because I had forgotten so much of the plot If possible, I forgot just how MUCH I love this book I think it is my number one favorite book ever I can t wait to continue with book number 2, and eventually read all three in the series.
EDIT 6 2 19Kkkkkkkk I wrote this review like 3 years ago, but for some reason, it keeps popping up in my feed, and I keep getting questions about why I DNF d the book, why I didn t like it, etc To clear up any remaining confusion, my personal reasons for disliking it were as follows 1 Needlessly graphic content, poorly handled 2 Thoroughly unlikable hero 3 Unhealthy use of the good girl redeems bad boy trope There ya go dusts off fingers original REVIEWSorry, guys Can t finish this one I do not like Christian Fiction Romance, and that s a fact My friend wanted me to try it because it s her favorite book everbut nope Nope I JUST DON T LIKE IT.
This was my first foray into Christian Fiction and I had very low expectations, anticipating a preachy text with so so writing and the occasional miracle thrown in And at times, this book can be all those things But Rivers trump card is her characters, and before I knew it I was in love, really in love, with these people I was shocked at how much I cared, and how quickly I ve enjoyed better writing, and not all of Rivers points hit the mark for me, but I ve come across few characters that I ve loved as much as Hadassah I had to put the down the book at least a dozen times because she made me want to cry not out of sadness or pity at her incredibly difficult situation, but because she wasso good I am not easily moved, but she could not have won me overcompletely She is the kind of character that impresses, influences and inspires the reader long after the book has been put down I found myself looking at my life and wanting to make changes in that way I handle adversity, the way I express love and the way I view sacrifice For that alone, I have to give this book four stars.
Hadassah her family is killed and she s taken from her home and put into slavery She was born a Jew being a Jew is both a Nationality and religion and no one suspects that she is a Christian She s seen as a non threat because of her plain looks but it s her inner beauty that draws people to her She s also Julia s faithful, humble, and obedient servant Marcus Valarian is a wealthy man in his early 20 s In our modern world we would consider him a manwhore because he has a different woman all the time He is very handsome and has an air of confidence about himself Julia Valerian Marcus s teenage sister She s spoiled, selfish, and vain Her outer beauty is the envy of many women and catches the eyes of many men Atretas a warrior in his country he is taken and made into a gladiator He s treated like an animal caged and forced to fight and kill to stay alive All this is done for the entertainment of the Romans He s fueled by his hatred of Romans and what they ve done by taking him from his homeland.
The beginning of this story is not what will draw you to it It s like reading the Old Testament where you are learning about the history of what is happening Once you get past that part the story takes off So, if you start the book and feel like maybe this isn t for you because it drags a little just know once you are about a fifth of the way into the book you ll have a hard time putting it down My all time favorite book is Redeeming Love which happens to be by this author I was asked if this book surpasses Redeeming Love as my favorite Here s the thing, RL is pure romanceabout one couple While AVITW is about several people and it s filled with so much scandal that my jaded self loved it But I can t pick which one I lovebecause it feels like picking a favorite kid and who does thatBut don t let the words Christian fiction hold you back from giving this book a try This book has manwhores, backstabbers, murderers, gladiators, schemers, aborters, forbidden romance, and the list goes on SERIES A continuing story.